Hearsay

From Criminal Defense Wiki
Revision as of 21:33, 3 July 2010 by Ibjadmin (talk | contribs) (→‎=)
Jump to navigationJump to search

Background

In the United States, testimonial evidence is hearsay if:

  1. a statement
  2. made our of court
  3. by the declarant
  4. offered for the truth of the matter asserted.
  • Statement - A statement may be an oral or written assertion and it may also be nonverbal conduct of the person.
  • Declarant - Declarant is a person making a statement. Neither a machine nor an animal are considered declarants under the hearsay rule.
  • Offered for the truth of the matter asserted - In certain cases evidence may be admissible because it is not offered for the truth of the matter asserted. For instance, the evidence may be for its:
  1. Effect on the listener (notice)
  2. Verbal Act / Publication. [Words have independent legal significance.]
    1. Simply because it was said (defamatory statement)
    2. or because the statement itself is all that matters "I accept" for contract formation.
  3. Impeachment during Cross-examination. In this case, the evidence is not offered for the truth, it is offered to prove the inconsistency of the witness.
  4. Circumstantial evidence of the speaker's state of mind, aka Consciousness of Innocence

Hearsay even includes the witnesses own testimony about what she said prior to trial.

  • Example: "I told Dexter it was raining outside."


Hearsay should be inadmissible at trial because the evidence suffers from defects which cannot be remedied. First, the testimony is offered without an oath. Second, the demeanor or the witness cannot be gauged when the testimony is delivered by a third part. Finally, the witness cannot be cross-examined by the defendant. Because of these defects, the defendant cannot test the witnesses reliability, memory, ability to perceive or their sincerity.

Hearsay Exceptions

In the United States there are several exceptions to the hearsay rule.


See Evidence