Difference between revisions of "Right to Counsel (Trial)"

From Criminal Defense Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 25: Line 25:
 
'''Table of Contents'''
 
'''Table of Contents'''
  
===Rights with Police ===
+
== Rights/ Protections from Police ==
 
* [[Arrest]]
 
* [[Arrest]]
 +
* [[Confessions]]
 +
* [[Pretrial Identification]]
 +
* [[Right to Counsel]]
 
* [[Right to Silence]]
 
* [[Right to Silence]]
 
* [[Search and Seizure]]
 
* [[Search and Seizure]]
* [[Right to Counsel]]
 
* [[Confessions]]
 
* [[Pretrial Identification]]
 
  
===Rights at Detention===
+
== Rights during Detention ==
 +
* [[Freedom from Punishment]]
 
* [[Right to Counsel]]
 
* [[Right to Counsel]]
 
* [[Right to Habeas Corpus]]
 
* [[Right to Habeas Corpus]]
* [[Right to be free of punishment]]
 
 
* Right to medical care
 
* Right to medical care
  
===Rights at Trial===
+
== Rights at Trial ==
* [[Right to a Fair Trial]]
+
* [[Double Jeopardy]]
* [[Right to Notice of Charges]]
+
* [[Legality Principle]]
* Right to Trial by Jury
+
* [[Presumption of Innocence]]
 
* [[Right to Compulsory Process]]
 
* [[Right to Compulsory Process]]
 
* [[Right to Confront Witnesses]]
 
* [[Right to Confront Witnesses]]
 +
* [[Right to Counsel (Trial)| Right to Counsel]]
 +
* [[Right to Fair Trial]]
 +
* [[Right to Notice of Charges]]
 
* [[Right to a Speedy Trial]]
 
* [[Right to a Speedy Trial]]
* [[Right to Counsel (Trial)| Right to Counsel]]
+
* Right to Trial by Jury
* [[Presumption of Innocence]]
 
* [[Double Jeopardy]]
 
 
 
===Sentencing===
 
  
* Right to sentence free of torture
+
== Sentencing ==
* [[Right to sentence without cruel or unusual punishment]]
 
 
* [[Death Sentence]]
 
* [[Death Sentence]]
* Right to fines that are not excessive
 
 
* [[Ex Post Facto Punishment]]
 
* [[Ex Post Facto Punishment]]
 +
* [[Freedom from Cruel or Unusual Punishment]]
 +
* Freedom from Torture
 
* [[Right to Appeal]]
 
* [[Right to Appeal]]
 +
* Right Not to be Fined Excessively
  
===Rights in Prison===
+
== Rights in Prison ==

Revision as of 13:52, 1 June 2010

Background

Assistance of counsel is the cornerstone of a defendant's constitutional right to counsel and has



"[T]he right to assistance of counsel is an essential ingredient in our system of criminal jurisprudence, rooted deeply in our concept of a fair trial within the adversarial context." People v. Felder, 47 N.Y.2d 287, 295-296 (1979). Thus, in absence of waiver by the defendant, effective assistance of counsel requires the presence of a licensed attorney-at law. Id. at 293.

In Felder, the court held that representation by a person masquerading as an attorney constituted a per se violation of his constitutional right to assistance of counsel.

Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

In Strickland v. Washington,466 U.S. 668 (1984), the United States Supreme Court held that for a defendant to make out a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, the defendant must show that 1) counsel's performance was deficient in that it fell below an objective standard of reasonableness and 2) that counsel's deficiencies so prejudiced his case so as to render the outcome of his trial unreliable and therefore unfair.

Per se Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

In the United States, the right to counsel may be strictly construed. If a client is unknowingly represented by an individual masquerading as an attorney, he will have a claim of per se ineffective assistance of counsel. In a per se case, the court should not apply harmless error analysis. The mere fact that the defendant was not represented by an attorney can result in remand for a new trial. "[T]he right to assistance of counsel is an essential ingredient in our system of criminal jurisprudence, rooted deeply in our concept of a fair trial within the adversarial context." People v. Felder, 47 N.Y.2d 287, 295-296 (1979). Thus, in absence of waiver by the defendant, effective assistance of counsel requires the presence of a licensed attorney-at law. In Felder, the court held that representation by a person masquerading as an attorney constituted a per se violation of his constitutional right to assistance of counsel.

Other jurisdictions have held similarly.

Rights of the accused

Table of Contents

Rights/ Protections from Police

Rights during Detention

Rights at Trial

Sentencing

Rights in Prison