Difference between revisions of "China Criminal Defense Manual - Questioning the Witness"

From Criminal Defense Wiki
Jump to navigationJump to search
Line 71: Line 71:
 
'''Example:''' Isn't it true that my client called the police, and waited for them at the scene?
 
'''Example:''' Isn't it true that my client called the police, and waited for them at the scene?
  
 +
 +
==PREPARING FOR THE PROSECUTION TO QUESTION YOUR CLIENT==
 +
 +
#The theory of most prosecution questions promotes the following false logic:
 +
##Story has changed from the original account or is different from the police's account,
 +
##The defendant is lying, and so therefore,
 +
##He must have committed the crime.
 +
#Prepare your client for the prosecutor's tone.
 +
#Your client should answer the prosecutor as he or she answered you, with the same voice inflection, the same eye contact, and a body language that indicates they are telling the truth. 
 +
#Approach expert questions that produce damaging evidence carefully.  These questions must be answered directly by the defendant, with no attempt to either evade or explain.  The defendant's body language must not convey any effort to evade touchy questions. 
 +
*Evasion makes the client look untruthful.
 +
*Explanations can become opportunities for a prosecutor to start tearing holes in the defendant's account. 
 +
*Therefore, let the client know that you can return to these issues during re-questioning and clean up some damage.  During re-questioning, be sure to ask questions that will advance your theory of the case. 
 +
#If the defendant does not know the answer, he or she should not be afraid to say "I don't know."  This may be especially important if a prosecutor tries to make your client admit to a certain number, or quantity: 
 +
*A prosecutor will try to show that your client incorrect about something, anything at all:  A frequent trick is to ask how long the red light lasted, how many meters it was across the room, or how many beers were consumed, etc. 
 +
*Even if the defendant first says that he or she does not know, the prosecutor may badger them to assent to an estimate, or a range.
  
 
==DEFENSE WITNESS EVALUATION==
 
==DEFENSE WITNESS EVALUATION==

Revision as of 11:04, 21 April 2010